На даній строрінці Ви маєте можливість ознайомитись з переліком провідних рішень ЄСПЛ та деякими позиціями ЄСПЛ висловленими в провідних рішеннях. щодо статті 5 Конвенції (право на особисту свободу та особисту недоторканність).
Рішення ЄСПЛ , де формулюються загальні принципи застосування статті 5 Конвенції в справах проти України:
Leading Repetitive | Case | 47889/08 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 27/03/2018 | Date Final Judgment: 27/06/2018
2 Leading Cases: 23543/02 – VOLOKHY v. Ukraine , 40583/15 – Ignatov v. Ukraine Ill-treatment by an off-duty police officer
Leading Repetitive | Case | 34015/07 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 27/04/2017 | Date Final Judgment: 27/07/2017
2 Leading Cases: 40107/02 – KHARCHENKO v. Ukraine , 40583/15 – Ignatov v. Ukraine Degrading treatment of a minor by police
Leading Repetitive | Case | 40583/15 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 15/12/2016 | Date Final Judgment: 15/03/2017
1 Leading Case: 40107/02 – KHARCHENKO v. Ukraine | 89 Repetitive Cases Unlawful arrests, unlawful and lengthy detention on remand.
Leading Repetitive | Case | 20808/02 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 04/03/2010 | Date Final Judgment: 04/06/2010
1 Leading Case: 66561/01 – MERIT v. Ukraine | 3 Repetitive Cases Unjustified restriction of detainees’ contacts with their families.
Leading | Case | 1291/03 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 12/03/2009 | Date Final Judgment: 12/06/2009
10 Repetitive Cases Unlawful interference with the applicant’s right to respect for their correspondence while in detention on remand.
Leading Repetitive | Case | 17116/04 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 17/01/2013 | Date Final Judgment: 17/04/2013
5 Leading Cases: 40107/02 – KHARCHENKO v. Ukraine , 33108/05 – OSHURKO v. Ukraine , 15825/06 – YAKOVENKO v. Ukraine , 2 more … Failure to ensure the applicant’s safety while in detention.
Leading Repetitive | Case | 54825/00 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 05/04/2005 | Date Final Judgment: 12/10/2005
3 Leading Cases: 28827/02 – ISAYEV v. Ukraine , 39042/97 – KUZNETSOV v. Ukraine , 14057/17 – Sukachov v. Ukraine | 58 Repetitive Cases Poor conditions of detention and lack of adequate medical treatment.
Leading Repetitive | Case | 28827/02 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 28/05/2009 | Date Final Judgment: 28/08/2009
1 Leading Case: 66561/01 – MERIT v. Ukraine | 25 Repetitive Cases Excessive length of civil and criminal proceedings; absence of an effective remedy
Leading | Case | 2452/04 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 19/04/2012 | Date Final Judgment: 19/07/2012
1 Repetitive Case Arbitrary placement in psychiatric hospital and subsequent unlawful retention.
Leading Repetitive | Case | 2570/04 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 06/09/2007 | Date Final Judgment: 06/12/2007
1 Leading Case: 67531/01 – GORSHKOV v. Ukraine Use of force on a remand detainee suffering from mental disorder; handcuffing for seven days whilst in detention in the disciplinary cell; lack of adequate medical treatment and assistance.
Leading | Case | 29971/04 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 18/12/2008 | Date Final Judgment: 18/03/2009
3 Repetitive Cases Conditions of detention and medical care issues
NECHIPORUK AND YONKALO v. Ukraine
Leading Repetitive | Case | 42310/04 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 21/04/2011 | Date Final Judgment: 21/07/2011
3 Leading Cases: 32092/02 – YAREMENKO v. Ukraine , 38722/02 – AFANASYEV v. Ukraine , 40107/02 – KHARCHENKO v. Ukraine | 1 Repetitive Case Ill-treatment/torture by police and lack of effective investigation
Leading Repetitive | Case | 22429/05 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 15/11/2012 | Date Final Judgment: 15/02/2013
1 Leading Case: 38722/02 – AFANASYEV v. Ukraine | 6 Repetitive Cases Unlawful seizure of property and use of force by the police; lack of effective investigations
Leading Repetitive | Case | 33108/05 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 08/09/2011 | Date Final Judgment: 08/12/2011
1 Leading Case: 19246/10 – MOKALLAL v. Ukraine | 3 Repetitive Cases Failure to meet positive obligations to protect physical integrity of detainees and to provide with timely medical assistance.
Leading | Case | 39884/05 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 19/01/2012 | Date Final Judgment: 19/04/2012
Unlawful arrests and unlawful and lengthy detention on remand.
Leading Repetitive | Case | 4494/07 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 07/11/2013 | Date Final Judgment: 07/02/2014
1 Leading Case: 40107/02 – KHARCHENKO v. Ukraine Ill-treatment / torture by police and lack of effective investigation.
Leading Repetitive | Case | 60846/10 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 31/03/2011 | Date Final Judgment: 15/09/2011
2 Leading Cases: 38722/02 – AFANASYEV v. Ukraine , 40107/02 – KHARCHENKO v. Ukraine Different malpractices in the course of extradition proceedings.
Leading Repetitive | Case | 49872/11 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 30/04/2013 | Date Final Judgment: 30/07/2013
1 Leading Case: 40107/02 – KHARCHENKO v. Ukraine Circumvention of legislation by prosecutors and judges in the context of criminal investigations in order to restrict liberty for reasons other than those permissible under the Convention
Leading | Case | 46193/13 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 09/10/2014 | Date Final Judgment: 09/01/2015
Unlawful arrests and unlawful and lengthy detention on remand.
Leading Repetitive | Case | 6492/11 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 03/07/2012 | Date Final Judgment: 19/11/2012
1 Leading Case: 40107/02 – KHARCHENKO v. Ukraine Circumvention of legislation by prosecutors and judges in the context of criminal investigations in order to restrict liberty for reasons other than those permissible under the Convention
Leading Repetitive | Case | 2775/07 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 11/07/2013 | Date Final Judgment: 11/10/2013
2 Leading Cases: 17988/02 – ZHOGLO v. Ukraine , 40107/02 – KHARCHENKO v. Ukraine Unfair criminal proceedings owing to lack of impartiality of judge.
Leading | Case | 45797/09 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 26/02/2015 | Date Final Judgment: 06/07/2015
involuntary hospitalization and confinement in psychiatric hospital in the course of an administrative proceedings
Leading Repetitive | Case | 43611/02 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 15/10/2015 | Date Final Judgment: 15/01/2016
1 Leading Case: 46082/99 – KLYAKHIN v. Russia Various breaches of the applicant’s rights to liberty and security, and the right to privacy, by the authorities of Ukraine and the Russian Federation, in the course of unlawful transfer from Ukraine to the Russian Federation.
Leading | Case | 2204/07 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 20/10/2016 | Date Final Judgment: 20/01/2017
Protection of rights in detention.
Leading | Case | 12317/06 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 05/06/2014 | Date Final Judgment: 05/09/2014
Protection of rights in detention and of family life.
Leading Repetitive | Case | 19246/10 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 10/11/2011 | Date Final Judgment: 10/02/2012
1 Leading Case: 2440/07 – SOLDATENKO v. Ukraine
Leading Repetitive | Case | 65518/01 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 06/09/2005 | Date Final Judgment: 06/12/2005
1 Leading Case: 61333/00 – TREGUBENKO v. Ukraine Freedom of expression / protection of rights in detention / access to and efficient functioning of justice.
Leading | Case | 67531/01 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 08/11/2005 | Date Final Judgment: 08/02/2006
Protection of rights in detention.
Leading | Case | 40107/02 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 10/02/2011 | Date Final Judgment: 10/05/2011
Protection of rights in detention.
Leading | Case | 24652/04 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 15/09/2011 | Date Final Judgment: 15/12/2011
Access to and efficient functioning of justice and protection of rights in detention.
Leading | Case | 29912/05 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 08/12/2011 | Date Final Judgment: 08/03/2012
Protection of rights in detention.
Leading | Case | 2440/07 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 23/10/2008 | Date Final Judgment: 23/01/2009
13 Repetitive Case Extradition / deportation – protection against ill-treatment and of rights in detention – conditions of detention and transportation.
Leading | Case | 28189/04 | Ukraine | English | Judgment Date: 21/12/2010 | Date Final Judgment: 21/03/2011
Protection of rights in detention.
Додатково для більш зручного пошуку надаємо посилання на вибірку рішень у форматі .doc